VPL1/2 Victoria Men's Best and Fairest
The birth of the National Premier Leagues Victoria in 2014 witnessed a rebranded semi-professional second tier, and with it came a Best and Fairest award which provided the next generation with an opportunity to claim personal honours. Sean Seavill claimed the first ever NPL2 Best and Fairest, with Brandon Barnes going back-to-back in 2017 before moving up to the top flight. In 2020, a third tier was introduced, but that and the following season were cut short owing to COVID-19, with the first award at that level honoured in 2022. From 2024, the NPL brand was dropped from the second and third tiers, with the Victorian Premier League resurrected after over a decade in mothballs.
VPL1 (formerly NPL2)
| Season | Player | Club |
| 2014 | Sean Seavill | Dandenong City |
| 2015 | Matteo Ballan | Bulleen Lions |
| 2016 | Brandon Barnes | Dandenong Thunder |
| 2017 | Brandon Barnes | Dandenong Thunder |
| 2018 | Phil Petreski | Box Hill United |
| 2019 | Jose Ramires | Whittlesea Ranges |
| 2020 | Not awarded | |
| 2021 | Not awarded | |
| 2022 | Corey Thomas | Moreland City |
| 2023 | Stephen Lawless | Werribee City |
| 2024 | Connor Bell | Preston Lions |
VPL2 (formerly NPL3)
| Season | Player | Club |
|---|---|---|
| 2022 | Andrew Mullett | Nunawading City |
| 2023 | Redouane Sarakh | North Sunshine Eagles |
| 2024 | Callum Schorah | Goulburn Valley Suns |
